Complete Guide to Choosing a Concealed Carry Pistol

Finding the right concealed carry pistol is one of the most important decisions you’ll make for personal protection. This guide will help you choose a pistol that fits your body, lifestyle, and skill level while ensuring you can carry comfortably and shoot accurately when it matters most.

Browse our complete selection of handguns

Understanding Concealed Carry

Concealed carry means keeping a firearm hidden on your person in public. The goal is effective personal protection while remaining discreet. Your concealed carry pistol should be:

  • Reliable: Functions every single time
  • Concealable: Hides under normal clothing
  • Comfortable: Can be worn all day without discomfort
  • Shootable: Accurate enough to hit your target under stress
  • Accessible: Can be drawn quickly when needed

The best concealed carry gun is the one you’ll actually carry every day.

Key Factors to Consider

Body Type and Clothing Style

Your physical build and typical wardrobe significantly impact what you can conceal:

Larger frames:

  • Can conceal compact and even full-size pistols more easily
  • More clothing options for concealment
  • May prefer larger grips for better control

Smaller frames:

  • Subcompact and micro-compact pistols work best
  • May need specialized carry positions
  • Lighter guns reduce carry fatigue

Clothing considerations:

  • Tucked shirts require appendix carry or deep concealment holsters
  • Untucked shirts/jackets allow more carry positions
  • Seasonal changes affect carry options (winter coats vs. summer t-shirts)

Caliber Selection

The eternal debate, simplified:

9mm (Recommended for most carriers)

  • Excellent balance of power and shootability
  • Higher capacity than larger calibers
  • Less recoil means faster, more accurate follow-up shots
  • Abundant, affordable ammunition
  • Modern defensive ammo is highly effective
  • Used by law enforcement and military worldwide

380 ACP (Excellent for ultra-compact guns)

  • Smaller guns mean better concealment
  • Manageable recoil in lightweight pistols
  • Adequate stopping power with quality defensive ammo
  • Good choice for recoil-sensitive shooters
  • Perfect for deep concealment needs

.40 S&W

  • More recoil than 9mm
  • Lower capacity
  • Excellent stopping power
  • Good option if you already own .40 caliber

.45 ACP

  • Significant recoil in compact guns
  • Lower capacity (typically 6-8 rounds)
  • Proven stopping power
  • Larger grip may be harder to conceal
  • Best for experienced shooters

Bottom line: 9mm offers the best combination of capacity, shootability, and effectiveness for most people.

Shop handgun ammunition

Size Categories Explained

Micro-Compact (Ultra-Concealable)

Characteristics:

  • 3-3.3″ barrel
  • 6-10 round capacity
  • 10-16 oz weight
  • Extremely easy to conceal

Best for:

  • Deep concealment situations
  • Ankle or pocket carry
  • Backup guns
  • Hot weather/minimal clothing
  • Smaller-framed individuals

Trade-offs:

  • Snappier recoil
  • Shorter sight radius (harder to aim precisely)
  • Smaller grip (may not fit larger hands)
  • Less capacity

Popular examples: Sig Sauer P365, Springfield Hellcat, Ruger LCP II, Glock 43

Subcompact (The Sweet Spot for Many)

Characteristics:

  • 3.5-4″ barrel
  • 10-15 round capacity
  • 16-24 oz weight
  • Excellent balance of size and shootability

Best for:

  • Daily carry for most people
  • Inside-the-waistband (IWB) carry
  • Appendix carry
  • All-season concealment

Trade-offs:

  • May print slightly more than micro-compacts
  • Still manageable for most body types

Popular examples: Glock 19, Sig P320 Compact, Springfield XD-S, Smith & Wesson M&P9 Compact

Compact

Characteristics:

  • 4-4.5″ barrel
  • 12-17 round capacity
  • 24-30 oz weight
  • Nearly full-size performance

Best for:

  • Larger individuals
  • Colder climates (more layers)
  • Primary home defense/carry gun
  • Those who prioritize shootability

Trade-offs:

  • Requires good holster and belt
  • May be difficult in summer clothing
  • Heavier for all-day carry

Popular examples: Glock 19, CZ P-10C, Sig P320 Carry

Action Types

Striker-Fired (Most Popular)

How they work: Partially cocked striker is released by trigger pull, firing the gun.

Advantages:

  • Simple operation (pull trigger, gun fires)
  • No external hammer to snag on clothing
  • Consistent trigger pull every time
  • Easy to maintain
  • Generally lighter weight
  • More affordable

Best for: Most concealed carriers, especially beginners

Popular models: Glock series, Sig P365/P320, Springfield Hellcat, Smith & Wesson M&P series

Double-Action/Single-Action (DA/SA)

How they work: First shot is heavy double-action pull, subsequent shots are lighter single-action.

Advantages:

  • Heavy first trigger pull acts as safety
  • Lighter follow-up shots
  • Can be carried with hammer down (safer)
  • Often very reliable

Considerations:

  • Two different trigger pulls to master
  • External hammer may print through clothing
  • Typically heavier
  • Requires more training

Popular models: Beretta PX4 Storm Compact, Sig P229

Single-Action (1911 Style)

How they work: Hammer must be cocked manually or by slide cycling; light, crisp trigger pull.

Advantages:

  • Excellent trigger
  • Very accurate
  • Slim profile
  • Classic design
  • Great ergonomics

Considerations:

  • Carried “cocked and locked” (hammer back, safety on)
  • Requires training for safe handling
  • Manual safety adds step to draw
  • Lower capacity (typically 7-8 rounds in .45)
  • Often heavier

Popular models: 1911 Commander/Officer models, Springfield EMP

Revolver

How they work: Rotating cylinder holds cartridges; trigger pull rotates cylinder and fires.

Advantages:

  • Extremely reliable (no magazine to fail)
  • Simple to operate
  • Can’t jam
  • Very easy to verify loaded/unloaded status
  • Excellent for beginners who train properly

Considerations:

  • Low capacity (5-8 rounds typically)
  • Slower to reload
  • Heavier trigger pull
  • Can be bulky

Popular models: Smith & Wesson J-Frame (442, 642), Ruger LCR

Essential Features to Look For

Sights

Standard sights:

  • Three-dot: Simple, proven, and reliable
  • White outline rear: Faster target acquisition
  • Practice with whatever sights your gun has

Upgraded options:

  • Night sights: Tritium inserts glow in darkness
  • Fiber optic: Bright and fast in daylight
  • Red dot ready: Mounting plate for micro red dot sight

Recommendation: Night sights are worth the investment for carry guns.

Trigger

Key factors:

  • Pull weight: 4-6 lbs is typical for carry guns
  • Reset: Short reset allows faster follow-up shots
  • Wall and break: Predictable break improves accuracy

Test the trigger: At the store, dry fire (with permission) to feel the trigger. A good trigger should be smooth without excessive creep.

Ergonomics

Critical elements:

  • Grip texture: Aggressive enough for control, not so rough it’s uncomfortable
  • Grip angle: Should point naturally when you draw
  • Controls: Magazine release and slide stop should be easy to reach
  • Backstraps: Interchangeable backstraps allow customization

How to test: The gun should feel like an extension of your hand, not something you’re fighting to control.

Capacity

Consider your needs:

  • More rounds = more options if you need them
  • Modern subcompacts hold 10-15 rounds (9mm)
  • Micro-compacts hold 6-12 rounds
  • Carry spare magazine for any gun

Reality check: Most defensive encounters involve 2-3 rounds fired, but capacity provides peace of mind and options.

Reliability

Non-negotiable:

  • Your carry gun must function 100% of the time
  • Test with at least 200 rounds of defensive ammo
  • Never carry a gun you haven’t thoroughly tested
  • Clean and maintain regularly

Budget Guide

Entry Level ($300-$500)

Perfect for first-time carriers on a budget.

What to expect:

  • Proven reliability from major manufacturers
  • Basic sights (replaceable)
  • Standard features
  • May have polymer finish instead of Cerakote

Recommended models:

  • Taurus GX4 / G3C
  • Canik TP9 Elite SC
  • Ruger Security-9 Compact
  • Smith & Wesson SD9 VE

Important: Even budget guns can be reliable—test thoroughly.

Browse handguns

Mid-Range ($500-$800)

The sweet spot where quality meets value.

What to expect:

  • Excellent reliability from trusted brands
  • Better triggers out of box
  • Enhanced sights or optics-ready options
  • Improved ergonomics and finish
  • Strong aftermarket support

Recommended models:

  • Glock 43X / 48 / 19
  • Sig Sauer P365 / P365XL
  • Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus / M&P9 2.0 Compact
  • Springfield Hellcat / XD-S Mod.2
  • Walther PDP Compact

Why it matters: These guns have proven track records with thousands of armed citizens and law enforcement.

Browse handguns

Premium ($800-$1,500)

For those who want the best features and performance.

What to expect:

  • Superior triggers
  • Optics-ready with excellent sight systems
  • Enhanced finishes and corrosion resistance
  • Better factory support
  • Exceptional reliability
  • Modular systems with extensive customization

Recommended models:

  • Sig Sauer P320 X-Compact / P365XL / P229
  • HK VP9SK / P30SK
  • CZ P-10C / P-01
  • Staccato C2 (if budget allows)
  • Wilson Combat SFX9

Investment value: Premium guns often come with upgrades that would cost hundreds separately.

Browse handguns

Luxury ($1,500+)

Custom-grade performance for serious shooters.

What to expect:

  • Hand-fitted components
  • Match-grade triggers
  • Exceptional accuracy
  • Premium materials and finishes
  • Often custom or semi-custom

Recommended models:

  • Staccato C2 / CS
  • Wilson Combat EDC X9
  • Nighthawk Agent 2
  • Les Baer Stinger
  • Ed Brown Kobra Carry

Carry Positions Explained

Appendix (AIWB – 1 o’clock position)

Advantages:

  • Fastest draw
  • Easy to access while seated
  • Hard for someone to grab from behind
  • Gun stays in front where you can see it
  • Easy to re-holster while watching surroundings

Considerations:

  • Requires proper holster with claw/wing
  • May be uncomfortable when sitting
  • Muzzle points at femoral artery (training critical)
  • Not ideal for larger bellies

Best for: Active individuals, drivers, those who prioritize speed

Strong-Side Hip (3-4 o’clock for right-handed)

Advantages:

  • Traditional and proven
  • Comfortable for most body types
  • Easy to conceal with untucked shirt
  • Natural draw motion
  • Works well when sitting

Considerations:

  • Harder to access while seated in car
  • Can be grabbed from behind
  • May print more when bending over

Best for: Most people, especially beginners

Small of Back (6 o’clock)

Advantages:

  • Very concealable from front
  • Comfortable when standing

Considerations:

  • Dangerous in falls (back injury risk)
  • Difficult to draw
  • Slow access
  • Can’t re-holster safely

Generally not recommended by most instructors.

Pocket Carry

Advantages:

  • Ultimate concealment
  • Very casual appearance
  • No belt required
  • Easy access

Considerations:

  • Limited to very small guns
  • Must use pocket holster
  • Slower draw
  • Can print in tight pants

Best for: Micro-compact as backup or when deep concealment needed

Ankle Carry

Advantages:

  • Deep concealment
  • Works with dress clothes
  • Excellent backup gun location

Considerations:

  • Very slow to access
  • Requires bending/kneeling
  • Only works with micro-compacts
  • Not ideal as primary carry

Best for: Backup gun, seated work environments

Critical Accessories

Holster (Non-Negotiable)

Quality holster requirements:

  • Covers entire trigger guard
  • Holds gun securely (won’t fall out)
  • Allows full firing grip on draw
  • Kydex or quality leather
  • Specific to your exact gun model

Never use:

  • Universal holsters
  • Nylon holsters
  • Anything without trigger guard coverage

Expected cost: $50-$120 for quality holster

Top brands: Tier 1 Concealed, PHLster, JM Custom Kydex, Vedder Holsters, Crossbreed

Gun Belt

Why it matters: A proper gun belt keeps holster stable and gun concealed.

Look for:

  • Stiff/rigid construction
  • 1.5″ width
  • Rated for concealed carry
  • Quality buckle

Expected cost: $50-$100

Top brands: Blue Alpha Gear, Hanks Belts, Beltman, Nexbelt

Spare Magazine

Critical for:

  • Malfunction clearance (magazine is often the issue)
  • Backup ammunition
  • Reloads if needed

Carry options:

  • Magazine pouches
  • Pocket carry (with pocket holster)
  • Cargo pocket

Defensive Ammunition

Don’t carry range ammo for defense.

Quality defensive ammo:

  • Jacketed Hollow Point (JHP) design
  • Proven expansion and penetration
  • Premium brands

Top choices:

  • Federal HST
  • Speer Gold Dot
  • Hornady Critical Defense/Duty
  • Winchester PDX1 Defender

Test your defensive ammo: Fire at least 50-100 rounds of your carry ammo to ensure reliability.

Shop defensive ammunition

Weapon Light (Strongly Recommended)

Why:

  • Most defensive situations occur in low light
  • Positive target identification is critical
  • Avoids shooting wrong person

Recommended brands:

  • Streamlight TLR-7A / TLR-7 Sub (compact)
  • SureFire X300U
  • Modlite PL350

Browse firearm lights

Training Essentials

Before You Carry

Minimum requirements:

  • Complete concealed carry permit course
  • Practice drawing from holster (100+ reps)
  • Shoot at least 200 rounds through your carry gun
  • Understand your state’s self-defense laws
  • Know how to safely load, unload, and clear malfunctions

Ongoing Practice

Recommended minimum:

  • Dry fire practice: 10 minutes, 3x per week
  • Live fire: 50-100 rounds per month
  • Formal training class: At least once per year
  • Practice drawing from concealment regularly

Skills to maintain:

  • Quick, clean draw
  • Accurate fire at 3-7 yards
  • Shooting from cover
  • Shooting with one hand
  • Shooting while moving
  • Malfunction clearance

Finding Training

Resources:

  • Local gun ranges (group classes)
  • NRA courses
  • USCCA training
  • Private instructors
  • Online resources (Lucky Gunner, Warrior Poet Society)

Investment: Quality training is more important than an expensive gun.

Legal Considerations

Know your laws:

  • Concealed carry permit requirements vary by state
  • Reciprocity agreements between states
  • Restricted locations (schools, government buildings, etc.)
  • Use of force laws
  • Duty to retreat vs. stand your ground

Recommended:

  • Take a legal self-defense course
  • Consider CCW insurance (USCCA, US Law Shield)
  • Keep permit and ID on you when carrying
  • Understand when you can legally draw/use your firearm

Critical: You are legally and morally responsible for every round you fire.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Buying based on looks alone The coolest-looking gun might not fit your hand, conceal well, or be reliable. Function over fashion.

2. Choosing too small a gun While micro-compacts are easy to conceal, they’re harder to shoot accurately. Balance concealability with shootability.

3. Cheap holster A $500 gun in a $20 holster is dangerous. Invest in quality carry gear.

4. Not testing defensive ammo Every gun has ammunition preferences. Test your carry ammo to ensure reliability.

5. Carrying without training A gun is only useful if you can deploy it safely and accurately under stress.

6. Carrying inconsistently “I’ll carry when I think I might need it” doesn’t work. Carry every day or don’t bother.

7. Wrong size gun for body type Be honest about what you can actually conceal comfortably with your wardrobe and build.

8. Neglecting maintenance Carry guns get exposed to sweat, lint, and debris. Clean and lubricate regularly.

Choosing Your First CCW: Decision Matrix

If concealment is your top priority:

→ Micro-compact 9mm (P365, Hellcat, Glock 43X)

If shootability is your top priority:

→ Compact 9mm (Glock 19, P320 Compact, M&P9 2.0 Compact)

If you have small hands:

→ Single-stack or slim guns (Shield Plus, Hellcat, P365)

If you’re recoil sensitive:

→ Slightly larger compact 9mm or .380 ACP

If you’re on a tight budget:

→ Taurus GX4, Canik, Ruger Security-9

If maximum capacity matters:

→ Double-stack micro-compact (P365, Hellcat, Shield Plus)

If you want the easiest to shoot:

→ Compact 9mm with 4″+ barrel (Glock 19, CZ P-10C)

If you’re new to guns:

→ Striker-fired 9mm subcompact (easy operation, reliable, common)

Recommended Starting Packages by Budget

$600 Total Budget

  • Gun: Taurus GX4 or Canik ($350-400)
  • Holster: Vedder LightTuck ($60)
  • Belt: Hanks or Blue Alpha ($60)
  • Ammo: 200 rounds practice + 50 rounds defensive ($100)
  • Training: Online resources (free) + range time

$1,200 Total Budget

  • Gun: Sig P365 or Glock 43X ($550-600)
  • Holster: Tier 1 or PHLster ($90-110)
  • Belt: Blue Alpha Gear EDC ($80)
  • Weapon light: Streamlight TLR-7 Sub ($130)
  • Ammo: 400 rounds practice + 100 rounds defensive ($200)
  • Training: Basic concealed carry class ($150)

$2,000+ Total Budget

  • Gun: Sig P320 X-Compact or P365XL with optic ($700-900)
  • Holster: JM Custom or PHLster with light ($110-130)
  • Belt: Premium EDC belt ($90-100)
  • Weapon light: Streamlight or SureFire ($130-300)
  • Red dot optic: Holosun or Trijicon ($200-400)
  • Ammo: 500+ rounds practice + 200 rounds defensive ($300)
  • Training: Professional defensive pistol course ($300-500)

Breaking In Your Carry Gun

Before carrying for real:

  1. Field strip and clean (remove factory preservatives)
  2. Function check all controls and features
  3. Fire 200+ rounds of practice ammunition
  4. Test 50-100 rounds of your defensive ammunition
  5. Practice drawing from your carry holster (unloaded, at home)
  6. Shoot from concealment at the range
  7. Verify zero with your defensive ammo at typical defensive distances (3-7 yards)

Red flags to watch for:

  • Failure to feed
  • Failure to eject
  • Light primer strikes
  • Magazine dropping free unexpectedly
  • Sights not regulated to point of aim

If you experience issues: Don’t carry that gun until resolved. Contact the manufacturer or a gunsmith.

Maintenance for Carry Guns

After every range session:

  • Field strip and clean
  • Check for unusual wear
  • Lubricate per manufacturer specs
  • Function check

Monthly (even if not shot):

  • Wipe down exterior
  • Check ammunition for corrosion
  • Verify magazine spring tension
  • Check holster for wear

Quarterly:

  • Rotate defensive ammunition
  • Deep clean
  • Inspect recoil spring
  • Check sights and other components

Annually:

  • Replace recoil spring (high-round guns)
  • Professional inspection
  • Replace magazine springs
  • Refresh defensive ammunition supply

Final Thoughts

The best concealed carry pistol is:

  • Reliable: You trust it with your life
  • Concealable: Fits your body and wardrobe
  • Comfortable: You’ll carry it every day
  • Shootable: You can hit with it under stress
  • Familiar: You’ve trained extensively with it

Don’t overthink it: A reliable 9mm from a major manufacturer, quality holster, good belt, and regular training will serve you well. The difference between most modern carry guns is minimal—what matters most is your skill and mindset.

Remember: Carrying a gun is a serious responsibility. You must be:

  • Legally authorized
  • Properly trained
  • Mentally prepared
  • Physically capable
  • Morally sound

The goal is to never need your gun. But if you do, having the right one and knowing how to use it can save your life.

Still Have Questions?

Choosing the right concealed carry pistol is a personal decision, and our team at Arms East is here to help.

Shop by category:

Contact us:

Related guides:

Ready to find your perfect concealed carry pistol? Browse our complete handgun selection from top manufacturers.

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top